No surprise: Curlin Eclipses opposition (again)
January 27th 2009 05:45
It was no surprise to see Curlin win consecutive Eclipse Awards for Horse Of The Year. He dominated the voting and secured more than double the votes secured by second placed Zenyatta. Both second and third placed horses, Zenyatta and Big Brown respectively, easily won their own divisions of Older Female and Three-Year-Old Male. But it was interesting to see Zenyatta defeat Big Brown by a substantial margin in voting for horse of the year. Hard to imagine this midway through last year when Big Brown had secured two legs of the Triple Crown and was a crowd and media darling. The close of the year saw Curlin as gallant as ever, and the aura surrounding Zenyatta ever growing (she is an early favourite to win Horse Of The Year in 2009) - but Big Brown was missing in action.
Horse racing is made more interesting by the longevity of champions. Shooting stars will be judged accordingly by expert and fan alike.
(photo: Z)
The ill-fated Eight Belles was runner-up in the Three-Year-Old Fillies Award; while English St Leger winner Conduit easily won the Male Turf Horse Award, leaving the best grass horses that the US has to offer a long way behind.
The full list of voting is below:
Voting for the 38th annual Eclipse Awards
Horse of the Year
Curlin 153; Zenyatta 69; Big Brown 13; Raven’s Pass 2; Einstein (Brz) 1; Goldikova (IRE) 1; Peppers Pride 1; Voter Abstentions 2.
Two-year-old male
Midshipman 195; Vineyard Haven 32; Old Fashioned 7; Donativum (GB) 5; Desert Party 1; Run Away and Hide 1; Street Hero 1.
Two-year-old filly
Stardom Bound 236; Maram 2; Springside 2; Rachel Alexandra 1; Sky Diva 1.
Three-year-old male
Big Brown 219; Raven’s Pass 21; Conduit (Ire) 1; Tale of Ekati 1.
Three-year-old filly
Proud Spell 90; Eight Belles 71; Goldikova (Ire) 41; Indian Blessing 20; Music Note 20.
Older male
Curlin, 239; Albertus Maximus 1; Commentator 1; Go Between 1.
Older female
Zenyatta 240; Ginger Punch 2.
Female sprinter
Indian Blessing 138; Ventura 88; Intangaroo 13; Indyanne 1; Voter Abstentions 2.
Male sprinter
Benny the Bull 107; Midnight Lute 86; Street Boss 40; Bustin Stones 3; Fatal Bullet 3; Visionaire 1; Commentator 1; Voter Abstentions 1.
Male turf horse
Conduit (Ire) 175; Einstein (Brz) 31; Grand Couturier (GB) 11; Hyperbaric 5; Kip Deville 5; Red Giant 4; Court Vision 2; Henrythenavigator 1; Champs Elysees (GB), 1; Spirit One (Fr) 1; Voter Abstentions 6.
Female turf horse
Forever Together 137; Goldikova 94; Cocoa Beach (CHI) 6; Ventura 3; Mauralakana (Fr) 2.
Steeplechase
Good Night Shirt 217; Be Certain 1; High Action 1; Voter Abstentions 23.
Outstanding owner
Stronach Stables 47; IEAH Stables 46; Stonestreet Stables LLC and Midnight Cry Stables 29; Mr. and Mrs. Jerome S. Moss 27; Godolphin Racing 24; Zayat Stables 16; Augustin Stable 13; Maggi Moss 11; Robert Cole Jr., 10; Darley Stable 4; Heiligbrodt Racing Stable 2; H. Joe Allen 1; J. Paul Reddam 1; Juddmonte Farms 1; Mohammed bin Khalifa al Maktoum 1; WinStar Farm 1; Voter Abstentions 8.
Outstanding breeder
Adena Springs 139; Stonerside Stable 60; WinStar Farm 13; Juddmonte Farms 9; Brereton C. Jones 4; Eugene Melnyk 1; Edward P. Evans 1; Fares Farm Inc. 1; George Strawbridge Jr. 1; Hal and Patti Earnhardt 1; Maverick Production 1; Monticule 1; Voter Abstentions 10.
Outstanding trainer
Steve Asmussen 187; Bobby Frankel 15; Larry Jones 9; Bob Baffert 7; Rick Dutrow 5; Jerry Hollendorfer 4; Bill Mott 3; John Shirreffs 2; Mike de Kock 1; Anthony Dutrow 1; Scott Lake 1; Mike Maker 1; Kiaran McLaughlin 1; Todd Pletcher 1; Howard Wolfendale 1; Voter Abstentions 3.
Outstanding jockey
Garrett Gomez 210; Rafael Bejarano 11; Robby Albarado 9; Russell Baze 3; Kent Desormeaux 3; Ramon Dominguez 1; Alan Garcia 1; Julien Leparoux 1; Joe Rocco 1; Mike Smith 1; Voter Abstentions 1.
Apprentice jockey
Pascacio Lopez 150; Inez Karlsson 34; Abel Mariano 18; Sebastian Morales 3; Sheldon Russell 3; Lyndie Wade 2; Chamisa Goodwin 1; Xavier Perez 1; Grant Whitacre 1; Voter Abstentions 29.
Horse racing is made more interesting by the longevity of champions. Shooting stars will be judged accordingly by expert and fan alike.
(photo: Z)
The ill-fated Eight Belles was runner-up in the Three-Year-Old Fillies Award; while English St Leger winner Conduit easily won the Male Turf Horse Award, leaving the best grass horses that the US has to offer a long way behind.
Voting for the 38th annual Eclipse Awards
Horse of the Year
Curlin 153; Zenyatta 69; Big Brown 13; Raven’s Pass 2; Einstein (Brz) 1; Goldikova (IRE) 1; Peppers Pride 1; Voter Abstentions 2.
Two-year-old male
Midshipman 195; Vineyard Haven 32; Old Fashioned 7; Donativum (GB) 5; Desert Party 1; Run Away and Hide 1; Street Hero 1.
Two-year-old filly
Stardom Bound 236; Maram 2; Springside 2; Rachel Alexandra 1; Sky Diva 1.
Three-year-old male
Big Brown 219; Raven’s Pass 21; Conduit (Ire) 1; Tale of Ekati 1.
Three-year-old filly
Proud Spell 90; Eight Belles 71; Goldikova (Ire) 41; Indian Blessing 20; Music Note 20.
Older male
Curlin, 239; Albertus Maximus 1; Commentator 1; Go Between 1.
Older female
Zenyatta 240; Ginger Punch 2.
Female sprinter
Indian Blessing 138; Ventura 88; Intangaroo 13; Indyanne 1; Voter Abstentions 2.
Male sprinter
Benny the Bull 107; Midnight Lute 86; Street Boss 40; Bustin Stones 3; Fatal Bullet 3; Visionaire 1; Commentator 1; Voter Abstentions 1.
Male turf horse
Conduit (Ire) 175; Einstein (Brz) 31; Grand Couturier (GB) 11; Hyperbaric 5; Kip Deville 5; Red Giant 4; Court Vision 2; Henrythenavigator 1; Champs Elysees (GB), 1; Spirit One (Fr) 1; Voter Abstentions 6.
Female turf horse
Forever Together 137; Goldikova 94; Cocoa Beach (CHI) 6; Ventura 3; Mauralakana (Fr) 2.
Steeplechase
Good Night Shirt 217; Be Certain 1; High Action 1; Voter Abstentions 23.
Outstanding owner
Stronach Stables 47; IEAH Stables 46; Stonestreet Stables LLC and Midnight Cry Stables 29; Mr. and Mrs. Jerome S. Moss 27; Godolphin Racing 24; Zayat Stables 16; Augustin Stable 13; Maggi Moss 11; Robert Cole Jr., 10; Darley Stable 4; Heiligbrodt Racing Stable 2; H. Joe Allen 1; J. Paul Reddam 1; Juddmonte Farms 1; Mohammed bin Khalifa al Maktoum 1; WinStar Farm 1; Voter Abstentions 8.
Outstanding breeder
Adena Springs 139; Stonerside Stable 60; WinStar Farm 13; Juddmonte Farms 9; Brereton C. Jones 4; Eugene Melnyk 1; Edward P. Evans 1; Fares Farm Inc. 1; George Strawbridge Jr. 1; Hal and Patti Earnhardt 1; Maverick Production 1; Monticule 1; Voter Abstentions 10.
Outstanding trainer
Steve Asmussen 187; Bobby Frankel 15; Larry Jones 9; Bob Baffert 7; Rick Dutrow 5; Jerry Hollendorfer 4; Bill Mott 3; John Shirreffs 2; Mike de Kock 1; Anthony Dutrow 1; Scott Lake 1; Mike Maker 1; Kiaran McLaughlin 1; Todd Pletcher 1; Howard Wolfendale 1; Voter Abstentions 3.
Outstanding jockey
Garrett Gomez 210; Rafael Bejarano 11; Robby Albarado 9; Russell Baze 3; Kent Desormeaux 3; Ramon Dominguez 1; Alan Garcia 1; Julien Leparoux 1; Joe Rocco 1; Mike Smith 1; Voter Abstentions 1.
Apprentice jockey
Pascacio Lopez 150; Inez Karlsson 34; Abel Mariano 18; Sebastian Morales 3; Sheldon Russell 3; Lyndie Wade 2; Chamisa Goodwin 1; Xavier Perez 1; Grant Whitacre 1; Voter Abstentions 29.
| 47 |
| Vote |















