Buena Vista easily wins Japan Cup - but loses race after stewards' inquiry
November 29th 2010 07:44
Racing jurisdictions around the globe all have different interpretations of what constitutes sufficient interference to cause a winner to be disqualified.
(photo: blogger.com)
The Japanese apply the strictest interpretation - but sometimes it just seems all so ‘unjust’ in implementation.
On Sunday the favourite - and local Champion - Buena Vista ran home an easy (1 3/4 lengths) winner of the 30th Japan Cup. But in staging her withering finishing burst, jockey Christophe Soumillon allowed the champion mare to deviate off a straight line and she brushed subsequent 2nd placegetter Rose Kingdom.
While Soumillon was still celebrating the victory stewards launched an inquiry into the (minimal) interference. Some 30 minutes later Buena Vista was disqualified and Rose Kingdom announced as the new winner of the Japan Cup.
Logic would say that the best horse did not win the Japan Cup - coming as Buena Vista did from far behind Rose Kingdom, and easily sweeping past for a comfortable win. Sometimes the letter of the law appears harsh and unyielding.
Watch the replay and decide for yourself:
The 2010 Japan Cup:
(photo: blogger.com)
The Japanese apply the strictest interpretation - but sometimes it just seems all so ‘unjust’ in implementation.
On Sunday the favourite - and local Champion - Buena Vista ran home an easy (1 3/4 lengths) winner of the 30th Japan Cup. But in staging her withering finishing burst, jockey Christophe Soumillon allowed the champion mare to deviate off a straight line and she brushed subsequent 2nd placegetter Rose Kingdom.
While Soumillon was still celebrating the victory stewards launched an inquiry into the (minimal) interference. Some 30 minutes later Buena Vista was disqualified and Rose Kingdom announced as the new winner of the Japan Cup.
Logic would say that the best horse did not win the Japan Cup - coming as Buena Vista did from far behind Rose Kingdom, and easily sweeping past for a comfortable win. Sometimes the letter of the law appears harsh and unyielding.
Watch the replay and decide for yourself:
The 2010 Japan Cup:
| 87 |
| Vote |
subscribe to this blog










